Before you sign,pressure-test the numbers.
A compelling payback claim is only as good as its utility, market, equipment and financial assumptions. Know what to check before committing capital.
For early-stage project qualification. Not a final engineering study or investment recommendation.
A five-year payback claim can look convincing until you ask which tariff, revenues, installed costs and operating obligations produced it. The goal is not to dismiss proposals, but to make their investment assumptions testable.
Five things to verify before trusting the payback
The inputs and assumptions behind a proposal often matter more than the headline number.
Rate and demand assumptions
Does the model match actual tariffs, load shapes, demand charges and escalation?
Value stacking and eligibility
Are claimed incentives and market revenues accessible, compatible, and realistic?
Project cost and risk
Are installed costs, operating expense, performance and sensitivity cases included?
Claim vs. what to verify
| Proposal says | Review asks |
|---|---|
| Demand savings | Which exact tariff and peak periods? |
| Grid revenue | Which programs and eligibility? |
| Incentives | Are they available and qualifying? |
| Payback | What changes under downside cases? |
Evaluate the opportunity, not just the proposal
Compare the proposed technology with other configurations. Understand whether the site’s complete value potential is reflected and which risks still require work.
Eight things to verify in any commercial battery proposal
An attractive investment model can be undermined by one hidden tariff assumption or one unavailable program payment. These are the evidence categories to request before treating a proposal as a credible business case.
Real customer tariffs
Confirm electric accounts, tariff, supply contract, billing demand and relevant capacity or transmission rules.
Interval load and peak timing
Verify that proposed dispatch targets actual demand-setting intervals, not only modeled average loads.
Complete installed cost
Include equipment, EPC, controls, electrical integration, interconnection, site works and contingency.
Revenue eligibility
Document the named program, contract, metering, performance requirements and stacking restrictions.
Incentive assumptions
Validate current incentive terms, project qualification, ownership, tax treatment and timing.
Battery performance
Review capacity, usable energy, efficiency, degradation, warranty, availability and control strategy.
Ongoing costs and obligations
Include maintenance, software, insurance, utility fees, aggregator charges, replacement and disposal assumptions.
Downside sensitivities
Test lower program payments, higher costs, weaker dispatch, degradation, delay and changing customer operations.
Reference: DECH Screening Playbook.
Turn a headline payback claim into a transparent model
Suppose a proposal advertises a five-year simple payback. The number alone is not enough to accept or reject the investment. Each component should be traceable to documented inputs, calculations and contracts.
| Proposal claim | Evidence to request | What may be missing |
|---|---|---|
| “Demand savings cover most of the return” | Actual tariff, billing intervals, modeled peak reduction and dispatch strategy | Unshaved peaks, ratchets, operational conflicts |
| “The battery earns grid revenue” | Named program, eligibility, contracts, registration, payment structure | Metering, fees, availability, penalties and overlapping value |
| “Incentives lower capex” | Eligible project/owner, current program terms, timing and approval status | Qualification risk, tax assumptions, unavailable funds |
| “The system pays back in five years” | Full cash-flow model, cost assumptions, sensitivity cases and performance profile | Opex, degradation, downtime, financing and replacement costs |
Build your proposal evidence checklist
Mark the documents you have gathered. A check means evidence is on hand, not that DECH has reviewed or validated it.
0 of 8 evidence categories gathered
Gather the underlying documents before relying on a headline payback. Completion does not establish project feasibility or investment readiness.
Works locally in your browser. Nothing is uploaded or saved after reload.
Four red flags that deserve more investigation
A vendor quote may be a useful first input, but investment decisions should reflect the customer’s goals and a sufficiently complete value-stack analysis.
Energy tariffs, load shapes, utility territories and operating constraints vary too much for a generic estimate to substitute for a site assessment.
Confirm whether the customer can participate, whether an aggregator is needed and whether the revenue conflicts with other commitments.
Power rating, duration and dispatch strategy should be justified by the peak profile and targeted value streams.
Ask for a conservative scenario and sensitivity to changing rates, costs, incentive availability, operational use and performance.
Use the DECH Screening Playbook as the next step
A practical guide to defining the investment question, comparing DER options and moving from screening to diligence.
The right answer may be to refine the proposal, not reject it
The best due diligence ends in a decision that is proportional to the uncertainty in the project.
Separate what is known, modeled and unverified
Validated bill and tariff information is different from forecast program revenue. Installed cost from a detailed EPC quote carries different uncertainty from a preliminary technology allowance. Keep those categories separate so stakeholders understand what has actually been established.
Compare at least one alternative configuration when practical. A different battery duration, solar-plus-storage option, or non-capital load-management measure may produce a better outcome with fewer constraints.
The output should be a set of actions: advance to interconnection study, refine sizing, confirm program eligibility, seek revised vendor pricing or pause because critical evidence is missing.
Screen
Test the basic economics and value drivers.
Validate
Confirm site data, tariff and eligibility.
Engineer
Resolve design, interconnection and performance.
Commit
Approve capital only with a suitable risk case.
Questions buyers ask before taking the next step
Actual economics, operating constraints and program eligibility require site-level review.
How do I verify a vendor’s battery payback calculation?
Request the tariff and load inputs, equipment sizing, installed-cost breakdown, operational dispatch model, incentive and program evidence, ongoing costs and a conservative sensitivity case. Then test the assumptions independently.
Should demand-response revenue be guaranteed in a proposal?
Do not assume any revenue is guaranteed without examining the applicable signed terms, minimum performance, payment calculations, fees, availability requirements and program risks.
What is the difference between a screening estimate and a bankable study?
A screening estimate supports deciding whether to proceed. A bankable analysis generally requires more robust validated engineering, contracts, financing, operating performance and risk assessments.
Can DECH evaluate a proposal that includes solar or a generator?
DECH describes site-level screening for solar, batteries and generators. The precise depth and available analyses depend on the project and should be confirmed during a platform or consulting discussion.
Make the next conversation about evidence.
Use the Screening Playbook to organize your questions, then discuss the opportunity and its assumptions with DECH.